Timber Creek Pizza Co. was founded in 2004

and has become one of the most-frequented pizza

and sub restaurants in Lake Mills.

I was blown away by how good the pizza was!

I typically don't enjoy thinner pizzas and usually choose thicker pizzas with crust but this pizza had the right amount of cheese and toppings. I forgot quickly devoured the delicious pizza. 

Kirk Dennison · Facebook

They have hearty, loaded sandwiches or cheesy delicious pizza!  For healthier-minded people, you can ask for any sandwich to come in the form of a

wrap. Fresh squeezed lemonade instead of fountain soda was part of my daily lunch! Everything is made to order with quality, fresh ingredients. 

Chere Chancey - TripAdvisor


LUNCH T-F 11:00-1:45pm

Monday       CLOSED

Tuesday       5–7:30PM

Wednesday  5–7:30PM

Thursday      5–7:30PM

Friday          5–8:00PM

Saturday      5–8:00PM

Sunday         5-7:30PM

Timber Creek Pizza

134 E Lake St

Lake Mills, WI 53551

(920) 648-4277


Monday       CLOSED

Tuesday       11AM–7:45PM

Wednesday  11AM–7:45PM

Thursday      11AM–7:45PM

Friday          11AM–8:30PM

Saturday      11AM–8:30PM

Sunday        12PM--7:45PM